Proposed Tobacco Ordinance Updates

Provide feedback on a proposed ordinance that would establish a tobacco sales license, enact fees to ensure compliance, and raise the minimum age of tobacco purchase to 21 years old.

This topic is closed

65 registered responses

Do you support establishing a tobacco sales license in the City of Tempe?

	Response Percent	Response Count
Yes	75.4%	49
No	21.5%	14
Don't know	3.1%	2

Why or why not?

Answered: 46
Skipped: 19

Show Word Cloud

If a tobacco sales license is established, do you support the proposed fees to ensure compliance?

	Response Percent	Response Count
Yes	72.3%	47
No	23.1%	15
Don't know	4.6%	3

Why or why not?

Answered: 35
Skipped: 30

Show Word Cloud

Do you support increasing the minimum age for purchase of tobacco products to age 21?

	Response Percent	Response Count
Yes	75.4%	49
No	23.1%	15
Don't know	1.5%	1

Why or why not?

Answered: 43
Skipped: 22

Show Word Cloud

Do you currently use tobacco products?

	Response Percent	Response Count
Yes	27.7%	18
No	58.5%	38
I used to	13.8%	9

Do you currently own, manage or work at an establishment that sells tobacco products?

	Response Percent	Response Count
Yes	26.6%	17
No	70.3%	45
Prefer not to answer	3.1%	2

Do you have any other comments?

Answered: 33
Skipped: 32

Show Word Cloud

Michael Madden outside Tempe

April 1, 2023, 11:43 AM

Do you support establishing a tobacco sales license in the City of Tempe?
- Yes
Why or why not?

Tobacco products are potentially addictive and depending on which product is used, can be deleterious to one's health. If laws are established to monitor sales to minors, there must be penalties to enforce the laws. One penalty would be the removal of the license to sell products to anyone for repeated violations of the prohibition on sales to minors.
If a tobacco sales license is established, do you support the proposed fees to ensure compliance?
- Yes
Why or why not?

The fees should be used exclusively to pay for enforcement activities. Otherwise, enforcement activities are not likely to happen or not frequently enough to be effective.
Do you support increasing the minimum age for purchase of tobacco products to age 21?
- Yes
Why or why not?

Tobacco products are potentially addictive and depending on which product is used and can be deleterious to one's health. Similar substances like alcohol and marijuana have age 21 sale limitations. If laws are established to monitor sales to minors, there must be penalties to enforce the laws.
Do you currently use tobacco products?
- No
Do you currently own, manage or work at an establishment that sells tobacco products?
- No
Do you have any other comments?

These laws strike the correct balance between the public health need to protect youth but allow access for adults. Specifically, we should not restrict e-cigarettes (tobacco and other flavors included) because they are a proven lifesaving tobacco harm reduction strategy for adults who want to use nicotine but are unable or unwilling to quit the much more dangerous forms of nicotine like combustible cigarettes. Complete prohibition of products that adults want to use did not work for alcohol or marijuana and it will not work for e-cigarettes.

Tempe Forum is not a certified voting system or ballot box. As with any public comment process, participation in Tempe Forum is voluntary. The responses in this record are not necessarily representative of the whole population, nor do they reflect the opinions of any government agency or elected officials.

Your answers will NOT be saved

This is the form that was used to collect responses. It's here so you can try it and see how it worked when the topic was open.

The topic is now closed, and anything you enter into this form will not be saved.

OpenGov will share your response with the City of Tempe staff. Do you also want your response shown on this website?

Yes - show it with my name Yes - show it without my name No - just show it without my name to staff

* required

Read more about privacy >

What is a disruptive statement?

A statement

containing personal attacks, profanity, commercial advertising or content which is entirely off-topic, and/or
from a user who has falsified their registration information with the intent to post multiple statements in one topic or to misrepresent their city of residence.

Why does Open Town Hall monitor for disruptive statements?

OpenGov is a non-partisan company dedicated to building public trust in government and broadening civic engagement. Many people will not participate if the forum has disruptive statements.

The objective of the forum is to provide a safe place for residents to read what other residents are saying about a specific topic, and to express their views about a specific topic, without fear of being attacked.

Does Open Town Hall find many disruptive statements?

No. Disruptive statements are quite rare - less than one in a thousand statements are disruptive.

What does Open Town Hall do if they find a disruptive statement?

Open Town Hall

moves the statement to a different web page,
describes the problem in an email to the author, and
invites the author to change the statement.

Does Open Town Hall ever edit or delete statements?

Never. Only the statement's author can edit or delete a statement.

If I disagree with someone, can I post my opinion?

Yes. Open Town Hall encourages open dialog which, by necessity, includes disagreements.

How do I know if my statement is a 'disagreement' or a 'personal attack'?

Personal attacks are disparaging remarks which impute motives to a person's action. Statements of fact, or of your own opinion are generally not personal attacks.
Here are some examples of statements which are, and are not, personal attacks.

Personal Attack	Not A Personal Attack
He lied.	He said he did X, but in fact he did Y.
She misrepresented the truth.	I don't trust her.
He is greedy.	He is making plenty of money.
It is merely a power play on her part.	She will announce her candidacy soon.

What are my options to participate?

Tempe Forum has two participation channels:

The Registered Channel: Sign in before or just after you submit your response. Either way, Community Feedback will show your response on this website.
The Unregistered Channel: Don't sign in and remain anonymous. Community Feedback will just share your response with Tempe staff.

Note: The first time you sign in, you'll need to register (establish an account on Tempe Forum). Registration is free.

Why do I need to sign in to show my response on this website?

The City of Tempe has contracted with Community Feedback to monitor responses shown on this website.

To prevent any single user from dominating the forum, the City of Tempe restricts the number of responses any one user can post on selected topics. Registration helps Community Feedback enforce this restriction.
Users, staff and government leaders often want to know the neighborhood from which a response is posted. Community Feedback uses registration to show the neighborhood next to each response (not the address).
If a user posts a response that does not meet the City of Tempe guidelines for civility, Community Feedback uses the user's email address to invite the user to resolve the issue.

I'm concerned about privacy. Who will get my contact information and what will they use it for?

Community Feedback will get your contact information. The company is under contract with the City of Tempe to hold it in strict confidence per their privacy policy.

What other benefits do I get from signing in?

Since you'll see your own response on Tempe Forum, you'll be able to confirm that your response was posted as you intended.
You'll be able to change and/or delete your response as long as the topic is open.

I'm still very concerned about privacy. Is there a way for me to submit a response without registering?

Yes. Sign out, then set your privacy preference to be "No - just show it without my name to staff". You won't need to register.

What prevents an unregistered user from submitting multiple anonymous responses?

While no authentication procedure can perfectly detect every fraudulent registration, Community Feedback is able to secure the registered channel against systematic fraud: cases where users submit enough statements with fraudulent registrations to sway the overall interpretation of the feedback.

Community Feedback is unable to secure the unregistered channel against systematic fraud, because unregistered users are anonymous.

Neither the registered nor the unregistered channel represent a certified voting system or ballot box - and that caveat is footnoted on every page of feedback. Instead, both are additional channels for feedback to government.

Why are there two participation channels?

Users can participate on the registered channel (by signing in) or on the unregistered channel (by remaining anonymous). The City of Tempe offers both channels in order to broaden participation and maximize decision makers' insights.

The registered channel enables users to assure decision makers that their feedback comes from a real person in a specific neighborhood. It also enables users to participate in a public discussion on the website, as well as manage their own response after posting it.

The unregistered channel is for users who want to provide quick feedback without registering, and/or whose privacy concerns would prevent them from participating if required to register. Because many users with valuable insights will only share them anonymously, this channel gives decision makers the option to consider those insights in their deliberations.

What is OpenGov?

OpenGov is a non-partisan company whose mission is to broaden civic engagement and build public trust in government. The City of Tempe has contracted with OpenGov to administer Tempe Forum.

Please review the proposed ordinance and fees.

Proposed ordinance

Proposed ordinance with redlines

Do you support establishing a tobacco sales license in the City of Tempe?

Yes

Don't know

Why or why not?

If a tobacco sales license is established, do you support the proposed fees to ensure compliance?

Yes

Don't know

Why or why not?

Do you support increasing the minimum age for purchase of tobacco products to age 21?

Yes

Don't know

Why or why not?

Do you currently use tobacco products?

Yes

I used to

Do you currently own, manage or work at an establishment that sells tobacco products?

Yes

Prefer not to answer

Do you have any other comments?

What is your age? (will not appear if you chose to share other responses)

What gender do you identify with? (will not appear if you chose to share other responses)

Male

Female

Non-binary

Prefer not to answer

What is your race? Select all that apply. (will not appear if you choose to share other responses)

Name (will not appear if you chose to share other responses)

Address (will not appear if you chose to share other responses)

Email to be kept updated on the project (will not appear if you chose to share other responses)

What is a disruptive statement?

A statement

containing personal attacks, profanity, commercial advertising or content which is entirely off-topic, and/or
from a user who has falsified their registration information with the intent to post multiple statements in one topic or to misrepresent their city of residence.

Why does Open Town Hall monitor for disruptive statements?

OpenGov is a non-partisan company dedicated to building public trust in government and broadening civic engagement. Many people will not participate if the forum has disruptive statements.

Does Open Town Hall find many disruptive statements?

No. Disruptive statements are quite rare - less than one in a thousand statements are disruptive.

What does Open Town Hall do if they find a disruptive statement?

Open Town Hall

moves the statement to a different web page,
describes the problem in an email to the author, and
invites the author to change the statement.

Does Open Town Hall ever edit or delete statements?

Never. Only the statement's author can edit or delete a statement.

If I disagree with someone, can I post my opinion?

Yes. Open Town Hall encourages open dialog which, by necessity, includes disagreements.

How do I know if my statement is a 'disagreement' or a 'personal attack'?

Personal Attack	Not A Personal Attack
He lied.	He said he did X, but in fact he did Y.
She misrepresented the truth.	I don't trust her.
He is greedy.	He is making plenty of money.
It is merely a power play on her part.	She will announce her candidacy soon.